Walt Mossberg headlined his recent article about the new Kindle Fire by calling it "A Grown-Up E-Reader with Tablet Spark." I was intrigued by his description, because that was exactly what I was looking for when I ordered mine. Now that I've had some hands-on experience with the device, I'm happy to say I got exactly what I wanted--and a little more.
Before I placed my order, I'd read a number of conflicting reviews about the Kindle Fire. Some I found to be right on target; others not so much. I'm not all that tech savvy, but because of all the buzz going around about this device--and because several friends have asked me about it, due to their own interest in purchasing one--I thought I'd comment briefly on my initial impressions.
First, it is not an "iPad killer," as it's been often dubbed. The KF lacks many of the features found on the Apple iPad. There's no camera (but for the life of me I have yet to figure out why anyone wants a camera on the iPad, awkward as it is to use. I much prefer the camera on my phone or, better yet, my Canon.). The KF has only 8 GB of built-in storage--but that doesn't really matter, given Amazon's unlimited cloud storage. It's smaller than the iPad at 7"--but that's a plus in terms of portability and holding it for any length of time when you're reading. The KF has no calendar or notepad. But it does have Amazon as its mother ship, and that's a very big plus.
Whether or not you'd be happy with the Kindle Fire depends, in my opinion, on your expectations for the device. In other words, what you want it to be. In my case, I primarily wanted the "grown-up e-reader" Mossberg mentioned. I like the options of reading in black on white, white on black, or the sepia/cream--my favorite. I also wanted a slightly smaller reader than the iPad that wouldn't become tiring when held for any length of time. I also wanted easy access to Amazon content, the ability to quickly check my e-mail while using the device rather than having to switch to another unit, and a better web browser than the one used on the earlier Kindle keyboard unit. The KF's browser is a little slower than the iPad's, but still quite an improvement over the older Kindle's. As far as I'm concerned, the "extras"--including movie, TV, and music streaming, plus several apps--are just that: extras.
As much as I appreciate my iPad, I have to admit that I also apreciate a few features that appear on the KF and not available to the iPad: An appealing and reasonable price. The size and light weight more desirable for an e-reader. Easy access to the Amazon marketplace. And unlimited cloud storage. The ease of use and great display I'd grown used to on the iPad are benefits of the KF as well.
I didn't want or need a "genuine tablet" to take the place of my iPad. I would never trade the work capability and utility of the iPad for the Kindle Fire, which is basically a device for Amazon content consumption. I wasn't looking for a mini-computer. There's not one out there that can begin to compare with my MacBook Air. I simply wanted exactly what Walt Mossberg wrote about: "a grown-up e-reader with tablet spark." That's what I got, and I'm completely happy with it. While I don't regret the bloated price I paid for my iPad some time ago, I'm very pleased--and somewhat impressed--with everything Amazon managed to cram into the KF for what even the critics concede to be a most reasonable price.
There are far more technical reviews all over the internet to help you get a better fix on the different devices available. This is just my way of providing a little more non-technical information for those of you who are still trying to make a decision between a full-fledged tablet or a unit that more closely resembles the Kindle Fire.
Good luck!
BJ
